Since the introduction of programmable logic controllers (PLCs), a variety of automation controllers have migrated to industrial applications, including programmable automation controllers (PACs) and today's edge programmable industrial controllers (EPICs). Users have more choices in terms of cost, footprint, input/output (I/O) density, fieldbus compatibility, communications, programming capabilities, and processing speed, and competition among leading controller suppliers has intensified.
For the market, diversity is often beneficial, but it can also be frustrating for engineers and end users. Choosing a particular control platform is a long-term investment, with associated expenses such as training and support contracts. Decision makers want to get their money's worth.
But before voicing support for the issue, it's worth taking a look at how the industry is evolving. What are the driving forces behind the different control solution trends? How are these trends currently playing out? How can users invest in automation in the future to ensure success?
Evolutionary Patterns of Industrial Controllers
Examining the advancements in automation and control over the past few decades, it is clear to see how a number of specific technology iterations have driven the development of new I/O and control features.
For example, when the first I/O systems were developed, field control and sensing devices also relied on electromagnetic and pneumatic components that were limited by physical properties that would compromise their longevity. Compact, low-voltage components, such as solid-state relays, drove the need for more options for users to integrate I/O directly into their systems. This led to the first modular I/O, at the same time that electronics companies were bringing high-tech computing into the mainstream. The sensitive electronics in these systems required external I/O in order to interact with the real world. This was the first serially addressable I/O rack, which was an alternative to rack-based I/O in PLCs.
The move from dedicated, stand-alone I/O devices to modular I/O to bus I/O exemplifies the concept of reuse in industrial control. Next-generation control platforms incorporate embedded I/O processing circuitry. Modules have expanded from 1 I/O channel to 32 channels, to now having I/O built into PLCs and other monolithic devices. In some cases, with proper configuration, each I/O channel can accept a variety of different signal types.
This model demonstrates how innovation spreads throughout an industry: over time, individual innovations become modular, work with other technologies, and then become embedded in those technologies as part of a new innovation cycle.
For PLCs and PACs, this model provides smaller controllers and I/O modules. Because math and programming processor functions are integrated directly into the control board and other devices such as I/O, transmitters, and network gateways, more computing power is realized "per square inch". Over time, the same pattern is reflected in the migration of new embedded communication interfaces and protocol standards to the controller.
Interconvergence of different technologies
The trend towards inter-convergence is intertwined with the integration cycle, and technological innovations from outside the industrial control market are gradually making their way into controllers. A look at the history of bus I/O shows how this trend has led to the development of new controller features.
From serial bus I/O, extended parallel I/O buses and other solutions that allowed mini- and micro-computers to interact with the I/O. This also inspired the idea of developing stand-alone I/O communication processors that separated the I/O from the computer and allowed any computer with a communication port to interact with it.
As I/O modules and processors improved, early hybrid controllers were also able to provide analog signal processing, which at the time was only available in distributed control systems (DCS). Since ladder logic programs (a PLC programming language) were not originally intended to handle analog data formats, this led to the creation of new programming languages for hybrid controllers.
Then, low-cost alternatives to the IBM PC began to flood the market. Since the PC is the primary control function of the hybrid system, this raises concerns about reliability. It was significant for vendors to develop industry-enhanced alternatives that combined the I/O, networking, and programming components of the earlier hybrid solutions into a single system, which became known as the PAC system.The PAC used the same processor as the PC and could provide a feature set that filled the gap between the low-cost, PLC-based discrete control and the high-cost, DCS-based process control niche market.
Innovations in high-tech companies and the PC market have opened up opportunities for industrial control. This trend is beginning to accelerate along with the increasing convergence between the fields of operations technology (OT) and information technology (IT). An example is the wave of mobile solutions that has emerged in recent years. It is also reflected in the drive for big data, cloud analytics and machine learning support, technologies born outside the industrial automation sector.
Controllers for the Future
As the trend toward deeper and deeper technology integration, greater convergence between industries, and greater connectivity between devices and systems continues to evolve, what will the controller of the future bring us?
How should engineers make their choices to ensure they stay on top of technology trends and help maximize the benefits to their organizations? Here are 3 tips to help manufacturing organizations choose the right control technology to achieve their goals.
1. Focus on design, not function
Understanding that technology will continue to improve over time, becoming more tightly integrated and embedded, it is necessary to prioritize investments in control systems that cannot be changed easily or quickly. Engineers need to emphasize the architecture of the control system rather than some of the eye-catching features of the day.
2. Look for external innovations
If engineers design systems that evolve over time and can keep pace with digital transformation, which in turn reduces maintenance and rework, it will impress end users, who will remember that the technology that defines the future usually comes from outside the industry.
3. Keep an open mind
While the battle for market share in proprietary technologies hinders innovation, supporting open standards opens up endless possibilities for everyone. Connectivity is one of the target metrics for Industry 4.0, and as connectivity increases, engineers need to invest in technologies that can create opportunities for different systems to work together.




