Designers of industrial automation systems face increasing challenges. Rack mounting such equipment can lead to increased size and thermal constraints. In harsh industrial environments, where sensitive electronic equipment requires tightly regulated voltages, customers demand higher performance and functionality. In Part 1 of this two-part series, we will explore the conflicting demands on industrial power supplies and the tradeoffs associated with common solutions.
Introduction
Industrial automation system design presents unique challenges. In fact, it is a story of conflicting demands. Introducing low-cost modular racks to house system components such as Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) and I/O modules places severe space and thermal constraints on engineers and solutions. These challenges are compounded by the need to ensure highly reliable operation in harsh environments susceptible to dirt, humidity and vibration.
In addition, customers expect enhanced functionality in subsequent generations of automation systems, all without increasing power consumption, equipment size, heat generation and cost. Such enhancements are often based on advances in electronics, but often come at a price: tighter power tolerances and surges in voltage levels that must remain stable while coming from less-than-perfect power supplies.
However, engineers don't want to spend valuable project time designing a power supply that goes unnoticed by customers and is often considered a waste of valuable space. Instead, the engineer prefers to focus on things that clearly differentiate his automation system from the competition.
Semiconductor suppliers have responded to the conflicting needs of industrial automation system designers by introducing modules that integrate many of the key functions of a power supply into a single device. However, modules designed to be powered by the 12, 24, or 48VDC supplies used by industrial automation systems must either be protected by voltage clamps or use asynchronous switching techniques to withstand the voltage spikes that plague the mains supply. Both solutions result in larger, more expensive and less efficient power systems - exactly what system engineers are trying to avoid.
This application note is part 1 of our two-part series on industrial control regulators. Here, we discuss industrial control architectures and the power supply architectures that make them unique, a design challenge. In part 2 of this series, we will discuss the next generation of power devices that utilize the latest silicon fabrication techniques combined with innovative chip designs.
Industrial Control Architecture
While 24VDC has become the de facto voltage for most industrial control applications (especially those utilizing PLCs), 12VDC is also common and is often used as a battery backup voltage or provided by alternative energy sources such as photovoltaic (PV) panels. The recent introduction of Power over Ethernet (PoE) has also encouraged industrial automation manufacturers to design equipment powered by the 48VDC supply specified in the standard. A typical industrial control system using a 24VDC power supply is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1. typical industrial control system.
The system consists of I/O modules for receiving information from sensors or sending commands to actuators, multi-channel digital inputs, multi-channel analog inputs and outputs, communication functions, and a processor (CPU) linked via a digital bus.The PLC typically provides the computing power. Power is supplied from the utility, stepped down to 24VDC, and distributed through the backplane.
A closer look at the system's power supply reveals greater complexity due to the different voltage and current levels required by the various system components. Figure 2 shows a small portion of the power architecture. the 120VAC/230VAC main power supply is initially stepped down to a standard 12VDC or 24VDC system backplane power supply using an industrial power module. At the system level, this backplane voltage is further stepped down to the lower voltage levels required by the individual components.

Figure 2. part of the power architecture of an industrial automation system.
For example, a PLC can consist of a microprocessor, digital signal processor (DSP), and field-programmable gate array (FPGA). These devices require a voltage range of 5V to 1V. However, the entire PLC may require up to 3.5A of current. Similarly, multi-channel analog I/O modules require ±15V and 5V supplies for various amplifiers, analog-to-digital converters (ADCs), and multiplexers (MUXs) with currents up to 500mA.
To complicate matters, designers need to consider transient voltage spikes ("overvoltages") that affect power supplies through events such as lightning strikes on the distribution network or by rapidly switching heavy loads that share the same power circuits as the industrial automation system. Voltage spikes can also occur in the power supply architecture itself, for example, when a power supply module steps down the supply voltage to 12VDC or 24VDC, especially when using switch-mode type devices.
These overvoltage events are so common that organizations such as the International Electrochemical Commission (IEC) recommend that engineers design their systems to withstand them. For example, IEC 60664, which deals with insulation coordination in low-voltage (1kVAC and 1.5kVDC) systems, states that "Class II" equipment (including types of equipment used in industrial automation) powered by utility-derived 24VDC supplies should be designed to withstand overvoltages of up to 60V.
DC-DC Voltage Regulation Basics
DC-DC voltage conversion (or "regulation") is big business, and semiconductor suppliers have invested heavily in developing a wide range of products for all applications. Devices are divided into two groups: low dropout regulators (LDOs), also known as linear regulators; and switching regulators.
When carefully matched to the operating characteristics of the application, switching regulators are typically more efficient over a wide input voltage range compared to LDOs. In addition, switching regulators can easily step up ("boost"), step down ("buck"), and invert voltages. (Note that some parts of industrial automation system power supplies require inverting voltages. In contrast, LDOs can only step down voltages.
Switching regulators have one disadvantage over easy-to-use LDOs: the design of the regulator is more complex. This is because output filtering is required to attenuate the voltage and current ripples generated by high-frequency switching operations. This causes problems for sensitive chips and generates electromagnetic interference (EMI). Despite this, engineers designing many contemporary applications increasingly favor switching regulators.
The key to the operation of switching regulators is the use of metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistors (MOSFETs) as switching devices. When the MOSFET is on, current flows both to the load and to an external inductor that stores the energy. When the MOSFET turns off, the inductor provides its stored energy to the load.
Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) is typically used to control the output voltage. The frequency is held constant and the pulse width ("on-time") is adjusted to provide the desired voltage. The high-frequency switching of the regulator limits losses in the system while maintaining a relatively stable voltage output over a range of inputs and loads.
In an asynchronous topology switching regulator (Figure 3), the energy stored in the inductor and then transferred to the load during the MOSFET off cycle does not flow directly to the load. Instead, it is propagated through an external Schottky diode. If the inductor is selected based on the expected load, the switching regulator will operate in continuous conduction mode, thus providing a stable regulated voltage.

Figure 3. asynchronous buck regulator circuit.
The ultimate efficiency of these switching regulators is determined by two main factors: the forward voltage drop of the external Schottky diode and the reverse leakage current characteristics of the device. In modern devices, the forward voltage drop is approaching a limit of about 0.3V. This doesn't sound like much, but it does lead to constant device consumption and reduced efficiency.
Replacing the Schottky diode with a MOSFET improves efficiency because the on-resistance (on R) of the transistor can be lowered using advanced fabrication techniques to keep the forward voltage (and losses) lower than the original diode. The operation of the two MOSFETs in this circuit must be synchronized so that one conducts and the other turns off.

Figure 4. synchronous buck regulator circuit.
The second MOSFET of the so-called synchronous regulator can be integrated into the module. In addition to eliminating the external Schottky diode, this simplifies the circuit design and reduces the bill of materials (BOM).
A side effect of the synchronous regulator design is that due to the switching operation of the two MOSFETs (i.e., doubling of inductive losses), current flows in both directions in the inductor. This is compared to the unidirectional flow in the asynchronous type. In synchronous regulators, the losses are usually small, but become larger at lower loads when the device efficiency may be lower than the equivalent asynchronous type.
Major semiconductor suppliers have addressed this shortcoming using a variety of techniques. For example, MaximIntegrated has introduced a series of high-voltage synchronous regulators, such as the MAX17503, with a MODE function that can be used to operate the device in three selectable modes of operation: PWM, pulse-frequency modulation (PFM) and discontinuous conduction mode (DCM). DCM also eliminates reverse inductor current to improve efficiency at lower loads, but does not skip pulses. This makes DCM suitable for frequency sensitive applications.
Summary
High-voltage, high-output-current synchronous regulators meet the needs of industrial automation for compact, efficient, and easy-to-design power modules. Several factors have contributed to the industrial power dilemma, but high-voltage synchronous regulator architectures that meet all needs are now available. While the current selection of suitable components is limited, the range continues to expand to meet all DC-DC voltage conversion requirements of a typical system, with power outputs ranging from a few hundred milliamps to several amps. In Part 2, we will discuss how new innovations in synchronous regulators are helping to solve the power consumption challenge.




